May, June or September
The local sources say it plainly: summer is for long stays and the beaches, spring and autumn for weekends of two or three days without the summer influx.
Itinerario
Two nights on an island of 3.7 km² sound like too many. They are not: they are exactly what it takes to stop visiting it and start being there.
Procida is the weekend island, and the local sources say so without going round the houses: summer is for long stays and for the beaches, while spring and autumn are for weekends of two or three days without the summer influx. The months that work best are May, June and September.
The advantage of two nights on a small island is not seeing more. It is taking the hurry out: you can climb to Terra Murata when the light is right rather than when it suits the ferry, you can go back twice to the same quay, you can accept that one afternoon it rains. And you can afford the thing the day trippers do not have: two evenings.
Marina Grande, with no plans
The full day: go up early, come down for lunch
The morning on the L2, the return without rushing
May, June and September. These are the three months in which the weekend works best: the season is under way, everything is open, and the crowds of the peak months are not there. In May the sea is still cool, so the programme leans towards the villages; in September the water is still warm and the light is the best of the year. The month-by-month details are in May, June and September.
Out of season, the weekend is still possible but it gets shorter: from October to May the last bus is around 21:00 and the evening ferry crossings disappear. Take out the beaches, keep the villages, and check the abbey, which opens to visitors from Holy Week to All Saints.
One date to note in any case: from 25 September Vivara can be visited on Friday, Saturday and Sunday only, with a single departure at 09:30. Which, for a weekend, is good news.
With children: take out the Chiaia, which takes about a hundred and eighty steps down and as many back up, and go straight to Chiaiolella, which has road access, shallow water and facilities. Sleep in that area and not in the upper villages.
If you have come to photograph: the good hour for Corricella from above is the morning, from the ridge at Santa Margherita Nuova; for the village from the water, the afternoon with a boat. They are two different photographs and you need both.
If you are here for the cinema: the Pozzo Vecchio beach is where Massimo Troisi recites Neruda’s poems to Beatrice in Il Postino, and the little square at Corricella carries his name. C1 bus from the harbour or twenty minutes on foot. The full route is in the locations of Il Postino.
If you have only one night: compress the lot into the two-day itinerary. If you have none at all, there is the one-day itinerary.
The format the island carries best: one day for the upper villages, one for the former prison and the sea, with the evening left to the people who sleep here.
The two upper villages in the morning, the quay at Corricella for lunch and the sea in the afternoon: the right order for an island you cross in forty minutes.
The trip from Naples with the real numbers: 25.40 EUR of ferry there and back, the full itinerary, and an honest comparison with the organised package from 85 EUR.
Reporter notebook
The local sources say it plainly: summer is for long stays and the beaches, spring and autumn for weekends of two or three days without the summer influx.
Palazzo d’Avalos wants two days’ notice and a minimum of two people; Vivara wants an online booking and takes 25 visitors per slot. Neither can be sorted out by turning up.
You gain a whole evening and you wake up already on the island. In summer there is the 21:05 hydrofoil from Naples; out of season the 21:55 ferry.

The circuit of the island at sunset, with music on board and an aperitivo of home-made snacks. The swim stop is optional.
✓ Verified GetYourGuide reviews

A full circuit of the island with swim stops and a guide on board in Italian, English and French. Changing rooms and showers are available at the lido you leave from.
✓ Verified GetYourGuide reviews
Two. With a single night the Saturday turns into a race; with two you have three full half-days and above all two evenings, which are when the island is at its best, after the day trippers have left.
May, June and September. The local sources point to spring and autumn as the season for weekends of two or three days, while summer is for long stays and the beaches.
Yes. The island measures 3.7 km² and you cross it on foot in about forty minutes: two nights hold the four villages, the abbey, the former prison, two beaches and, if you have booked, Vivara.
Very much so. You gain a whole evening and you avoid the Saturday morning queue. In summer there is the 21:05 Caremar hydrofoil from Naples, running from 1 June to 30 September; outside that period the last crossing is the 21:55 ferry.
Yes, but sleeping at Chiaiolella and taking the Chiaia out of the programme: that beach takes about a hundred and eighty steps on the way down and as many on the way back. Chiaiolella has road access, shallow water and facilities on the seafront.
Further reading